| 2019 | Brodie Richardson (Craigieburn/Willmott) | Not Played |
| 2018 | Mitchell Zadel (Altona Lakes) | Not Played |
| 2017 | Tom Catoggio (Royal Park) | Not Played |
| 2016 | Tom Catoggio (Royal Park) | Not Played |
| 2015 | J.Gardner (Centenary Park) | Not Played |
| 2014 | C.Naicker (Centenary Park) | Tom Catoggio (Royal Park) |
| 2013 | M.Urquhart (Camberwell) | C.Tan (Camberwell) |
| 2012 | J.Bannan (Growling Frog) | P.Cambell (Camberwell) |
| 2011 | S.Oliver (Centenary Park) | J.Flynn (Brighton) |
| 2010 | Not Played | |
| 2009 | J.Ford (East Malvern) | B.Meehan (Brighton) |
| 2008 | T.Scheppers (Centenary Park) | C.Brodrick (Centenary Park) |
| 2007 | T.Scheppers (Centenary Park) | B.Kantor (Glen Waverley) |
| 2006 | K.Deretic (Jubilee) | T.Maroulakos (Yarraview) |
| 2005 | R.Nicholson (Centenary Park) | D.O'Meara (Centenary Park) |
| 2004 | M.Georgeades (Craigieburn) | H.Klyn (Tirhatuan) |
| 2003 | J.McLeod (Brighton) | S.McDermott (Centenary Park) |
| 2002 | A.Halliday (Centenary Park) | M.Trevena (Centenary Park) |
| 2001 | A.Halliday (Centenary Park) | C.Mitchell (Creekside) |
| 2000 | A.Lonigro (Craigieburn) | S.McGowan (Craigieburn) |
| 1999 | M.Lewfatt (Glen Waverley) | A.Lonigro (Craigieburn) |
| 1998 | P.Mladenovic (Riverside/Ess) | P.Loughnan (Ringwood) |
| 1997 | M.Crooks (Westgate) | C.O'Brien (Riverside/Ess.) |
| 1996 | T.Mago (Westgate) | B.Nolan (Moorabbin) |
| 1995 | G.Campbell (Centenary Park) | D.Coulon (Forest Hills) |
| 1994 | G.Campbell (Centenary Park) | No Record |
| 1993 | G.Campbell (Centenary Park) | No Record |
| 1992 | D.Gascoyne (Greekside) | J.Robinson (Riverview) |
| 1991 | J.Louey (Elsternwick Park) | P.Mason (Olinda) |
| 1990 | C.Casey (East Malvern) | M.Tait (Ringwood) |
| 1989 | D.Semple (Centenary Park) | L.Shearn (Centenary Park) |
| 1988 | J.Glanz (Centenary Park) | Not Played |
| 1987 | J.Glanz (Centenary Park) | Not Played |
| 1986 | W.Urrutia (Wattle Park) | Not Played |
| 1985 | N.Carver | Not Played |
| 1984 | C.Wells (Frankston) | Not Played |
| 1983 | C.Wells (Frankston) | P.Parkinson |
| 1982 | C.Moore (Camberwell) | J.Game Jnr (Australasian) |
| 1981 | G.Allen (Churchill Park) | A.Cooper |
| 1980 | C.Hurwood | Not Played |
| 1979 | M.Perkins | Not Played |
| 1978 | M.Perkins | Not Played |
| 1977 | P.Urquhart (Northcote) | Not Played |
| 1976 | A.Hession | Not Played |
| 1975 | R.Law | Not Played |
| 1974 | T.Catoggio (Royal Park) | Not Played |
